A 24-carat pink diamond made $14.6 million in Geneva. The bigger lesson was in the colored stones

A diamond ring in a velvet box.
A diamond ring in a velvet box. Photo: The Now Time / Unsplash

Christie's sold the Bulgari Pink on Tuesday night in Geneva for CHF 12.1 million, more than $14.6 million. The stone is a 24-carat emerald-cut Fancy Intense Pink diamond set in a Bulgari ring from the 1950s, and it had been in one European noble family for about 70 years. Christie's had estimated it at CHF 10 to 15 million. Max Fawcett, the house's global head of jewelry, called it "the Mona Lisa of pink diamonds."

That was the headline. It was not the most interesting result of the week.

The stones that ran past their estimates

At Sotheby's on Wednesday, the Romanov Sapphire, a 197.80-carat unheated Ceylon sapphire from the Russian crown jewels, sold for CHF 4,122,000 against an estimate of CHF 850,000 to 1.7 million. It was worn by the Dowager Empress Maria Feodorovna at the 1903 Winter Palace ball, later belonged to the opera singer Ganna Walska, and now sits in a Cartier bracelet made in 2015.

The same pattern ran through the smaller lots, according to Rapaport's reporting on the Christie's sale. A 54.76-carat Ceylon sapphire brooch estimated at CHF 330,000 to 500,000 made CHF 1.6 million. A 5.39-carat Colombian emerald ring estimated at CHF 150,000 to 250,000 made CHF 972,800. A Van Cleef & Arpels Zip necklace and earring set from 1952, estimated at CHF 350,000 to 500,000, made CHF 1.1 million.

Meanwhile the big white diamond in the Christie's sale, a 21.69-carat D-color Harry Winston stone known as the Star of Sierra Leone VI, sold for CHF 832,000, at the low end of its estimate, Rapaport reported.

Why white diamonds are lagging

The weak spot is plain diamonds, and it starts at the mine. De Beers sold far more rough in its third quarter after cutting prices in July, but at an average of $97 a carat for the year so far, down 37 percent, according to Rapaport and The Namibian. Its rough price index is down roughly a fifth on a year ago. When the raw material keeps getting cheaper, finished white diamonds without a famous name have little to push them up.

Lab-grown stones sit at the far end of that curve. Wholesale prices for lab-grown rounds rose about 2 percent in the third quarter, the first increase in a while, but they still trade at roughly $73 to $142 a carat wholesale, according to analyst Edahn Golan, a small fraction of what most buyers paid at retail.

Our read: the premium is going to signatures and stones with a story, not to carat weight. Signed vintage pieces from Van Cleef and Cartier, and unheated colored stones with paperwork, sold for two to four times their high estimates this week. Large white diamonds sold for what the catalog said, or less.

What it means for what you own

Most people will never consign a Romanov sapphire, but the same logic applies to a Cartier Love bracelet or a Van Cleef Alhambra pendant. The maker's name and the paperwork carry the value. Keep the box, the certificate and the receipt, and if you own a colored stone, find out whether it has a lab report that says it is unheated, because that one line changes the price.

The premium is going to signatures and stones with a story, not to carat weight.

If you bought a lab-grown diamond, treat it as something to wear rather than something to sell. If you own a natural white diamond with no brand behind it, expect resale offers to stay soft while rough prices keep falling.

Sources

  1. Associated Press via CP24, “A 24-carat 'Bulgari Pink' diamond ring sells for over US$14.6 million at Christie's auction”
  2. AAP via Newcastle Herald, “The 'Mona Lisa' of pink diamonds sold at auction”
  3. Rapaport, “Bulgari Pink Diamond Rakes In Nearly $15M at Christie's”
  4. Outlook Luxe, “Sotheby's Geneva Auction: The Romanov Sapphire And Historic Royal Jewels”
  5. Royal Watcher, “Sotheby's Royal & Noble Jewels, 11 November 2026”
  6. Rapaport, “De Beers Sales Volume Jumps After Price Cut”
  7. The Namibian, “Namibia stays steady as De Beers' diamond output drops”
  8. INSTORE, “Lab-Grown Diamond Wholesale Prices Rise in Q3 2026”

The pieces in this story

All prices

What an unworn example resells for today, from the Jewl app.

See what your own pieces are worth.

Add the watches and jewelry you own. Jewl prices each one against the market and tracks your collection over time.

Download on the App Store
QR code that opens Jewl on the App StoreOn a computer? Scan with
your iPhone camera.

More stories

All stories